four note friday 2.47 | Photovoice's Axiological Commitments
Axiology is a branch of philosophy focused on values and ethics. Axiologies inform and shape methodologies in ways that are all-too-often implied rather than explicitly stated. Axiologies also shape us as human beings—the way we make sense of the world and our place in it. It shapes our judgments, thoughts, and behaviors. It shapes how we understand our relationships to one another.
Photovoice, including its many permutations, is a research methodology. I see it as a form of critical participatory action research. And, as most methodologies do, it comes with an imbedded set of axiological commitments that should be surfaced and made clearer within projects, particularly in academic research dissemination outlets such as conference presentations and journal articles.
Yet, what are these axiological commitments?
And how do we, as project facilitators, ensure alignment between these axiological commitments and how we are actually showing up within facilitated projects?
In this week's post, I share what I see as photovoice's axiological commitments, then share what those commitments look like in action.
Social Justice
The theories undergirding any given methodology provide us with clues about its axiological commitments. I've written about these theories before. In short, they include critical consciousness education, feminisms, and participatory documentary photography. When we think about these theories, the first axiological commitment comes into focus.
Each of the theories above were generated in response to some form of social harm. And each of the theories include ways to identify, name, address, and redress those social harms. This is social justice. Social justice includes recognition of harm(s), accountability for harm(s), and repair of harm(s).
Photovoice without an axiological commitment to social justice may not be photovoice. Not all photo elicitation projects are photovoice.
And while actually achieving social justice might not be possible, the pursuit is worthy because incremental change is still change.
Photovoice values the pursuance of social justice.
What this axiological commitment looks like in action is working alongside and in solidarity with folks from marginalized groups and/or with marginalized identities. It implores us to deploy the methodology such that harms are surfaced and the process of redresses those harms—and healing from those harms—is commenced.
Voice
Whose voices matter? I have lived long enough to know that certain voices matter more or less than others in certain contexts. In most contexts, voices with power matter more. In most situations, voices of those with privileged positionalities matter more. I could go on. And on.
Photovoice without an axiological commitment to marginalized voices is not photovoice.
Photovoice values the voices of the marginalized.
What this axiological commitment looks like in action is recognizing lived experience as a key source of knowledge and knowing and doing whatever is possible to really listen carefully to, collectively curate, and amplify the voices of the people closest to the topic or focus of the work.
Agency
Within photovoice projects, participants are not passive research subjects from whom data are extracted. They are capable human beings with real lives and real experiences and real joys and real pain. To the extent they are comfortable and willing, they are participants, collaborators, and co-researchers. They are asked to play a role in shaping the project and the work generated from that project. They have the agency to participate in the work to the extent they prefer. They have agency.
Photovoice without an axiological commitment to agency is not photovoice. It is extraction.
Photovoice values the agency of those involved as participants-collaborators-researchers.
What this axiological commitment looks like in action is inviting photovoice participants to the table as key decisions are being made about the project and all the project's unfurlings. It is deep listening. It is co-ownership. It is respect and decency.
Action
Photovoice is a form of critical participatory action research. Photovoice research is not meant to sit on a shelf. It is meant to change the world. Really.
Photovoice without an axiological commitment to action is knowledge creation for the sake of creating knowledge. Knowledge creation is important. It is vital. Photovoice project can generate new knowledge, but photovoice is not only about knowledge creation.
Photovoice values action as an integral part of inquiry.
What this axiological commitment looks like in action is ensuring knowledge dissemination plans are integrated into every facet of the project—from the very start. And those dissemination plans should include action-oriented outcomes. Questions such as who is the target audience for the results of this project? ought to be addressed early and often. Host an exhibition. Speak with lawmakers. Present ideas to administrators. Study policy change. Understand policy change strategies. Share information with those who create policy, implement policy, and are affected by policy.
What do you see as the axiological commitments of photovoice? What about some of the other research methodologies you have used? What are the differences? What about the similarities? How do your personal axiological frames square with photovoice?
🥹 Thanks for spending a moment with me this Friday.
💌 If you’re new here, welcome! I hope this space becomes one you look forward to each week.
📖 Interested in a book version of these posts? Check out the paperback and ebook!
📬 Have a question you want me to answer in a future post? Reach me at photovoicefieldnotes@gmail.com. I'd love to hear from you.
Thanks again for being here.
Warmly,
Mandy
photovoice field notes
https://www.photovoicefieldnotes.com/